Enhancing Profit and CO2 Mitigation: Commercial Direct Air Capture Design and Operation with Power Market Volatility
Zhiyuan Fan a b, Elizabeth Dentzer c, James Glynn d, David S. Goldberg e, Julio Friedmann f, Bolun Xu a . "Enhancing Profit and CO2 Mitigation: Commercial Direct Air Capture Design and Operation with Power Market Volatility." Engineering (2026).
https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2095809926001268
a Department of Earth and Environmental Engineering, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA
b Center on Global Energy Policy, Columbia University, New York, NY 10027, USA
c Department of Mechanical and Aerospace Engineering, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ 08540, USA
d Energy Systems Modelling Analytics Limited, Galway H91 HE9E, Ireland
e Lamont–Doherty Earth Observatory, Columbia University, New York, NY 10964, USA
f Carbon Direct, New York, NY 10004, USA
Abstract
Current decarbonization efforts are falling short of meeting the net-zero greenhouse gas (GHG) emission target, highlighting the need for substantial carbon dioxide removal methods such as direct air capture (DAC). However, integrating DACs poses challenges due to their enormous power consumption. This study assesses the commercial operation of various DAC technologies that earn revenue using monetized carbon incentives while purchasing electricity from wholesale power markets. We model four commercial DAC technologies and examine their operation in three representative locations including California, Texas, and New York in United States. Our findings reveal that commercial DAC operations can take financial advantage of the volatile power market to operate only during low-price periods strategically, offering a pathway to facilitate a cost-efficient decarbonization transition. The ambient operational environment such as temperature and relative humidity has non-trivial impact on abatement capacity. Profit-driven decisions introduce climate-economic trade-offs that might decrease the capacity factor of DAC and reduce total CO2 removal. These implications extend throughout the entire lifecycle of DAC developments and influence power systems and policies related to full-scale DAC implementation. Our study shows that DAC technologies with shorter cycle spans and higher flexibility can better exploit the electricity price volatility, while power markets demonstrate persistent low-price windows that often synergize with low grid emission periods, like during the solar “duck curve” in California. An optimal incentive design exists for profit-driven operations while carbon-tax policy in electricity pricing is counterproductive for DAC systems.
Keywords
Direct air capture; Carbon dioxide removal; Profit-driven decarbonization; Climate-economic trade-off; Power market integration; Electricity price volatility; Climate change; Carbon incentive policy; Optimization; Carbon tax
Technology and policy options for achieving net zero steel manufacturing in the United States
Francis GN Li a, Chris Bataille b, Seton Stiebert c, Taiba Jafari b, Olexandr Balyk b, and James Glynn b. "Technology and policy options for achieving net zero steel manufacturing in the United States." Energy Policy 211 (2026): 115124.
https://doi.org/10.1016/j.enpol.2026.115124
a Subtext Systems LLC, Lake Tahoe, Nevada, USA
b Center on Global Energy Policy, Columbia University, New York, USA
c Stiebert Consulting, Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Abstract
This paper explores strategies for achieving net zero emissions in the United States steel industry by 2050, consistent with the Paris Agreement. The US faces a pivotal moment in the lifecycle of its steel production fleet in the late 2020s, where the opportunity exists to integrate next generation clean steel technologies into the industrial base and become a global market leader in net zero steel by mid-century. Effective policy support at the federal and state levels will be essential for transitioning the most GHG-intensive production methods to cleaner alternatives during this upcoming window of opportunity. Our results indicate that the Inflation Reduction Act alone is unlikely to be sufficient to drive a timely transition to net-zero steel production, and that additional demand-side, trade-related, and post-IRA policy measures are required. The paper contextualizes U.S. steel production within global efforts, examining implications for technological change, energy demand, emissions reductions, and international trade using a geospatially detailed techno-economic model of steel production across 137 countries and 1000+ facility locations. Our analysis finds that the US is well positioned to be one of the first countries in the world to achieve net zero steel manufacturing and could make this transition using existing technologies, but the speed of transition and the resulting patterns of investment are sensitive to US policy choices on trade openness to the rest of the world and with close allies. Trade-restrictive pathways, while capable of accelerating domestic decarbonization, also entail higher costs and economic risks that must be carefully managed.
China Energy Transformation Outlook 2025
https://www.cet.energy/category/reports/
Lyu Wenbin, Wang Zhongyingm, Bai Quan, Zhao Yongqiang, Kaare Sandholt, Han Wenke
Energy Research Institute of the Chinese Academy of Macroeconomic Research
Director and Deputy Directors
Sun Ying
Energy Efficiency Research Centre
Bai Quan, Gu Lijing, Fu Guanyun, Zhang Jianguo, Yi Wenjing, Pei Qingbing, TianYushen, Liu Zhenghao, Zheng Xiongling, Ma Shaoyue
Renewable Energy Development Research Centre
Zhao Yonqiang, Zheng Yanan, He Ze, Wang Jingyi, Zhong Caifu, Tao Ye, Shi Jingli,Hu Runqing, Ren Dongming, An Qi
Energy, Environment and Climate Change Centre
Xiong Huawen, Yang Hongwei, Zhong Shan, Tan Qilu, Hui Jingxuan
Energy Economics and Development Strategy Centre
Tian Lei, Gao Hu, Liu Fan, Lin Huan, Li Hai, Yang Wantao, Wang Jiayi
Energy Sustainability Centre
Tian Zhiyu, Liao Hongyun, Fu Bi’an, Liu Hechuan, Yan Jun, Wang Lu, Wang Tianzi
Energy System Analysis Centre
Feng Shengbo, Liu Jian, Deng Liangchen, Fei Jiaying
International Energy Collaboration Research Centre
Zhu Yuezhong, Liu Jianguo, Li Dongya, Ji Shiyu, Liu Qiang
Administrative Office
Hou Wensen
Research Management and International Collaboration Division
Su Ming, Yao Mingtao, Zhang Siyao, Li Nan
The CET Project Administrative Office
Fan Lijuan, Gao Lianna, Tu Liang, Yu Fei, Wang Yue
Danish Energy Agency (DEA)
Management group
Ulrik Eversbusch, Jens Hein
Modelling team
Xu Jie, Matteo D’Andrea, Paolo Zuliani, Francesco Lovat Arranz, KonstantinosAthanasiou
Topic contributor
John Tang (district heating), Aimilia Pattakou (power market)
Senior consultant
Wang Xinnan
Ea Energy Analyses (Ea, Contracted by DEA)
Lars Møllenbach Bregnbæk, Phil Swisher, James Glynn, Helena Uhde, Sara Shapiro-Bengtsen, Jens Christian Rørbæk Kruse
Symbolic Regression for Modelling Decarbonisation Pathways in the Global Energy-Economy-Climate System
McDermott, James, James Glynn, Iain Morrow, and Evangelos Panos. "Symbolic Regression for Modelling Decarbonisation Pathways in the Global Energy-Economy-Climate System." In Proceedings of the Genetic and Evolutionary Computation Conference Companion, pp. 871-874. 2025.
https://doi.org/10.1145/3712255.3726704
Abstract
The ETSAP-TIAM Model is a process-based optimisation model of the global energy system, integrated with a climate and economy model that explicitly represents detailed energy technology processes including generation, transmission, and end-use across sectors. It provides a tool to inform policy by examining the effects of policy changes on outcomes. However, the model is complex, large, and unwieldy. In this paper, we develop a suite of Genetic Programming Symbolic Regression (SR) surrogate models. The benefits are both interpretability and instant response of the new model to parameter changes. Considering both regression performance and model complexity, we compare a SR system with strong baselines, exploring different points on the performance—interpretability curve. Finally, we read and interpret several of our models.
Aryanpur, V., Balyk, O., Glynn, J., Gaur, A., McGuire, J., & Daly, H. (2024). Implications of accelerated and delayed climate action for Ireland’s energy transition under carbon budgets. npj Climate Action, 3(1), 97.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s44168-024-00181-7
Abstract
Limiting global warming requires the effective implementation of energy mitigation measures by individual countries. However, the consequences of the timing of these efforts on the technical feasibility of adhering to cumulative carbon budgets—which determines future global warming—are underexplored. Moreover, existing national studies on carbon budgets either overlook integrated sectoral interactions, path dependencies, or comprehensive demand-side strategies. To address this, we analyse Ireland’s mitigation pathways under equal per-capita carbon budgets using an energy systems optimisation model. Our findings reveal that delayed mitigation brings forward the need for a net-zero target by five years, risks carbon lock-in and stranded assets, increase reliance on carbon dioxide removal technologies and leads to higher long-term mitigation costs. To keep the Paris Agreement targets, countries must set and meet accelerated mid-term mitigation goals and address energy demand.
Conceptualising global cultural transformation—developing deep institutional scenarios for whole of society change
Hughes, I., Hernandez, A. M., Glynn, J., Hynes, W., & Gallachóir, B. Ó. (2024). Conceptualising global cultural transformation—developing deep institutional scenarios for whole of society change. Environmental Research Letters, 19(9), 094050.
https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1748-9326/ad6d7f/meta
Abstract
This paper aims to contribute to current efforts to improve methodologies to find more ambitious and integrated strategies to jointly pursue the Paris climate target and other Sustainable Development Goals. It suggests a means of further expanding the underlying societal perspectives in scenarios modelling through a model of deep institutional innovation for sustainability and human development (DIIS), which aims to reframe the narrative from sociotechnical transition to deep global cultural transformation. The paper posits the need for capturing irreversible transformation change through a fundamental reimagining of the key social institutions that together comprise contemporary societies. To illustrate the application of the DIIS framing to pathway scenarios an indicative scenario is offered to indicate the radical global cultural changes required to move to pathways capable of bringing about greater sustainability and human flourishing.
China Energy Transformation Outlook 2024
Wang Zhongying, Han Wenke, Kaare Sandholt, Bai Quan, Zhao Yongqiang, Yang Hongwei, Zheng Yanan, Gu Lijing, An Qi, Tao Ye, Liu Jian, He Ze, Shi Jingli, Zhong Caifu, Hu Runqing, Zhang Jianguo, Fu Guangyun, Yi Wenjing, Pei Qingbing, Tian Yushen, Guo Minxiao, Su Ming, Fan Lijuan, Hou Wensen, Anton Beck, Lars Grundahl, Xu Jie, Wang Xinnan, Natasha Amalie Gjerløv Fiig, Bjarke Nepper-Rasmussen, Gregers N.S. Larsen, Matteo d'Andrea, Lars Bregnbæk, Anant Atul Visaria, Lars Pauli Bornak, Christian Bang, Peter Børre Eriksen, David Sandalow, James Glynn, Kevin Tu, Sally Qiu, Yan Sheng, Geir Yngve Hermansen, Yan Qin, 2023, China Energy Transformation Outlook. Energy Research Institute of Chinese Academy of Macroeconomic Research.
https://www.cet.energy/category/reports/
Key Findings of the CETO2024 Report
With significant efforts, the energy transformation can make a decisive contribution to China’s efforts to achieve a carbon-neutral society before 2060. Under the Baseline Carbon Neutrality Scenario (BCNS) and the Ideal Carbon Neutrality Scenario (ICNS), with the accelerated development of energy transformation technologies (including negative carbon technologies such as carbon capture) and related industries, China’s energy system can achieve net-zero carbon emissions before 2060, paving the way to make the Chinese society as a whole carbon neutral before 2060. Through modelling analysis and thematic research, the group came to five important conclusions:
Energy conservation and efficiency are prerequisites for the energy transformation, and sustained electrification is an effective way to move towards carbon neutrality.
Building a power system with wind and solar as the mainbody is a necessary choice for energy transformation.
Building a highly intelligent power grid is a central measurement to establishing a new type of power system.
Scientific and technological innovation is the driving force of the energy transformation, and new energy productivity breeds vast market opportunities.
Energy system and mechanism reforms must continue to deepen while simultaneously establishing a legal framework to drive the energy transformation.
In summary, China’s energy transformation is a long-term and challenging societal project. China will simultaneously advance its energy transformation across five areas: electrify energy consumption and improve energy efficiency, decarbonise energy supply, enhance interaction between energy supply and demand, commercialise energy technologies, and modernise energy governance. At the same time, China should strengthen international cooperation on energy transformation, exploring pathways together with the global community. In doing so, China will not only ensure the smooth progression of its own energy transformation but also contribute significantly to the global effort.